So, everywhere you look on the blogosphere Christians are talking about the 'Superman as Christ Figure' allusion in the new movie
Superman Returns. (For example,
here,
here,
here and
here.) And if you watch the movie, you're pretty much hit over the head with it.
But
shouldn't it be obvious that Jesus isn't anything at all like Superman? At least the orthodox position is that
Jesus was a human, just like you and me--not an alien coming down whole from heaven.
Jesus did not have superpowers. When Jesus does miracles and wonders it is because he is in total connection with the Father, not because there's some kind of difference in the DNA strands or because he's made of some different substance. This is what made people disown Jesus--not because he was weird, but because he was
too normal. "He did not consider equality with God something to be grasped, but made himself nothing..."
Jesus did not save the world--that is, in anyway that the world wanted to be saved. Pontius Pilate was definately the number one pick for Lex Luthor of Jesus' day--powerful, cruel and corrupt. Everyone was looking to the skies--"Someone save us! Send us a savior!" And here comes Jesus plodding down the road, a thorn in his toe, a bad cold and sweaty. What Jesus gives us is the power of his resurrection; he does not/has not slayed the villians.
Jesus did not come to promote a humanist message. In the trailer to
Superman Returns there is the now famous line:
"They can be a great people, Kal-El - they wish to be. They only lack the light to show the way. For this reason above all, their capacity for good, I have sent them you - my only son."
The message we come away with in the movie is that Superman has come to show us a better way, how to be good humans. While the above quote does have the ring of John 3:16, Christians should immediately notice that this is opposite of John 3:16. Jesus was all about the work of the Father, about bring glory to the Father--not about providing a new message for optimistic humanism.
So isn't it quite funny that we would make a connection between Superman and Jesus when Jesus is the total opposite of Superman? If you tried to make an anti-Superman, you would get Jesus. And if you tried to make an anti-Jesus, he would look like Superman. It's like Warren Buffet as Christ Figure.
A possible explanation:
Perhaps we have have to make a distinction between Jesus and
Christ-figure. Christ-figure is a Messianic idea, a person who comes from above to save the world and set things right. In this way, Superman is a Christ-figure--while Jesus is not. Jesus is everything we didn't want in a Christ-figure, and thus we killed him.
So, I suppose we accept Superman as Christ-figure...as long as we remember that Jesus wasn't anything like we imagine a Christ-figure should be. Jesus came, but we, dissatisfied, still await our Superman, who will do all the things Jesus should've done, like stop evil men and heal everybody and be generally well-liked by everyone.